HON’BLE SUPREME COURT · SOURCE-REVIEWED NOTE
V. Venugopala Varma Rajah v. Commissioner of Agricultural Income-tax, Trivandrum, Kerala
Civil Appeal No. 266 of 1969
[1972] 1 SCR 1000 ·
Kerala Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1950: section 9(1) · Indian Income-tax Act, 1922: section 16(1)(c) discussed
Sources & disclosures includedDownload original judgment / order
3-judge bench; unanimous judgment delivered by K. S. Hegde, J. · K. S. Hegde, J. · A. N. Grover, J. · H. R. Khanna, J.
Assessment years: 1959-60
01 · Facts of the case
A 1909 family arrangement put properties in male members' possession for enjoyment while joint status, ultimate ownership, maintenance responsibilities and reversion to the Karnavan remained (SCR pp.1000-1005; PDF pp.1-6).
Source: Primary judgment: facts
02 · Discussion by the Hon’ble Court
Income diverted before reaching the assessee may be excluded, but income applied after receipt to discharge an obligation remains taxable. The members received on the family's behalf and used the income for maintenance; the revocable arrangement did not confer an absolute property right (SCR pp.1005-1009; PDF pp.6-10).
Source: Primary judgment: discussion
03 · Judicial decision
The Court dismissed the assessee's appeal with costs (SCR p.1009; PDF p.10).
Source: Primary judgment: decision
04 · Outcome / in whose favour
In favour of Revenue: the allotted-property income was deemed agricultural income of the family (SCR pp.1008-1009; PDF pp.9-10).
Source: Primary judgment: outcome
05 · AKHB REVIEW POINT
AKHB analysis: distinguish an antecedent overriding title from an obligation governing use after receipt, and test ownership, revocability and reversion. Modern statutory attribution rules require separate verification (based on SCR pp.1005-1009; PDF pp.6-10).
Source: Primary judgment: review point
Source & verification
Download original judgment / order · Open cited source rendition
Full 10-page SCR source asset read in page-preserving text and visually inspected; adjacent-report boundaries were checked.
- Exact source bytes, SHA-256 and 10-page count match catalogue asset 1972_1_1000_1009; every page was read and visually inspected.
- The source verifies the stated case identity, bench, statutory issue and operative order.
- No exact source-hash, asset-ID, SCR-citation, docket or same-judgment match was found in the published corpus or reviewed archive.
Statutory scope
The decision applies historical Kerala agricultural-income-tax and 1922 Act concepts; current family, trust and diversion rules were not checked.
Later treatment
Source checked 2026-10-11. Later judicial treatment and current statutory applicability have not been comprehensively checked; no current-law or citator clearance is represented.
Page references identify the supplied PDF; paragraph references identify the judgment unless stated otherwise.
Coverage, AI disclosure & professional disclaimer
Selected Supreme Court income-tax decisions and procedural orders checked against their identified sources. This collection is not exhaustive. The research catalogue has 2,569 indexed PDF assets, including alternate copies and incidental matches; that is not a count of unique or reviewed judgments. Historical and unreported coverage remains open.
AI-assisted research checked against the identified source. Extraction, interpretation or omission errors remain possible. Source review does not mean independent approval by a practising professional. Verify every material statement against the complete original judgment.
General research information only; not legal or tax advice, a certified judgment or a substitute for the full order. Applicability depends on facts, assessment year, statutory version and jurisdiction. Subsequent treatment is unverified unless a note expressly identifies the sources checked. Downloading does not create a professional engagement. Obtain case-specific advice before reliance.
The official 1961–2025 structural correspondence does not establish that a precedent applies under the new Act. Verify the enacted wording, commencement and transitional provisions separately.