HON’BLE SUPREME COURT · SOURCE-REVIEWED NOTE
Oriental Investment Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay
Civil Appeal 153 of 1954
[1958] SCR 49 ·
Indian Income-tax Act 1922, sections 66(1) and 66(2)
Sources & disclosures includedDownload original judgment / order
3-judge bench · N. H. Bhagwati · S. K. Das · J. L. Kapur
Assessment years: 1943–44 to 1948–49, excluding 1947–48
01 · Facts of the case
Investment company challenged dealer classification and taxation of share/property disposals. The Tribunal relied on memorandum objects and prior dealer claims, then refused reference; the High Court also refused.
Source: Primary report: SCR 50–54
02 · Discussion by the Hon’ble Court
Dealer versus investor classification involves applying legal characteristics to facts, a mixed question. Memorandum authority alone does not establish trading, and no-evidence or legally misdirected factual conclusions may be reviewable.
Source: Primary report: SCR 55–64
03 · Judicial decision
Appeal allowed and High Court order set aside; remitted for directing Tribunal to state two questions concerning supporting material and taxability as business profits. Costs of proceedings so far awarded to appellant.
Source: Primary report: SCR 64
04 · Outcome / in whose favour
Assessee obtained reference and remand; investor status and ultimate exemption were not finally adjudicated.
Source: Primary report: SCR 64
05 · AKHB REVIEW POINT
Distinguish enabling company objects, actual activity and legal inference. This decision only required stated questions to be answered. The later 1968 Oriental Investment decision already in the repository is a separate decision and must not be merged as this date.
Source: Primary report: SCR 63–64
Source & verification
Download original judgment / order · Open cited source rendition
Complete 16-page Supreme Court Reports scan. Any adjoining report fragments remain in the unchanged original and are excluded from this analysis.
Statutory scope
Historical legislation expressly identified in this note. This is not a decision under the Income-tax Act, 1961 or the Income-tax Act, 2025. Verify enacted wording, commencement, transition and subsequent judicial treatment independently before modern reliance.
Later treatment
Source checked 2026-10-23. Subsequent treatment and present-law applicability have not been comprehensively checked.
Page references identify the supplied PDF; paragraph references identify the judgment unless stated otherwise.
AI disclosure & professional disclaimer
This AKHB research note uses AI assistance and a preserved full-primary review, with refreshed exact original-byte verification. Independent human review is not represented.
General legal and tax research only; not legal or tax advice. Verify the complete judgment, applicable statutory version and subsequent treatment before reliance. AKHB REVIEW POINT is editorial analysis, not the Court’s holding.